Gray craftsman home with stone columns and a charcoal garage door

How do you choose exterior paint colors for a house?

How to choose exterior house colors: work from the roof and masonry, choose body, trim and accent together, understand undertones and LRV, pick sheens, and test samples the right way.

Back to blog · 5 min read

Short answer

Choose exterior colors by starting with what will not change (roof, stone, brick and windows), then pick a body, trim and accent color as a set. Check each color's undertone and light reflectance value (LRV), choose sheens for each surface, and test large samples on more than one side of the house in morning and afternoon light before deciding.

Key takeaways

  • The roof, masonry and windows stay after the paint is done, so they set the palette.
  • Most houses use a body color, a trim color and an accent color for the front door or shutters.
  • LRV runs from 0 (black) to 100 (white). Lower LRV colors absorb more light and heat.
  • On vinyl siding, Sherwin-Williams advises staying no darker than the original color unless you use a vinyl-safe color.
  • Test large samples outdoors. A Sherwin-Williams color director's advice: the larger the sample, the better.

Start with what is not changing

Your roof, brick, stone, concrete, window frames and gutters stay the same after the painters leave. Pull colors that work with them. Hold samples directly against the roofing and masonry, because a gray that looks neutral on a chip can clash with a warm brown roof or look blue next to red brick.

How many colors should a house have?

Most houses look best with three: a body color for the siding, a trim color for corner boards, fascia and window trim, and an accent color for the front door, shutters or another feature. Choosing all three together keeps the house from looking pieced together. Simple, modern homes sometimes use just two, with the body and trim in the same family and a single strong accent.

What are undertones and why do they matter outside?

An undertone is the hue a color leans toward underneath its main color, such as a gray that leans blue, green or purple, or a beige that leans yellow, green or pink. In Pro Remodeler, LP SmartSide's color marketing manager notes that newer grays have blue, purple or green undertones and that newer beiges lean subtly yellow and green. Undertones get stronger in large areas and in outdoor light, so two whites that look identical on a card can look very different on a house.

The easiest way to see an undertone is to compare samples side by side, and against a pure white sheet of paper.

What is LRV in paint?

Light reflectance value (LRV) is a number from 0 to 100 that measures how much light a color reflects: 0 is pure black and 100 is pure white. Paint makers list it on the color card or the color's web page. It tells you how light or dark a color will really read on the house, and, because dark colors absorb more sunlight, how much heat the surface will take on.

A general guide to LRV for exterior colors
LRVHow it reads outsideThings to know
Below 20Very dark: charcoal, black, deep navyAbsorbs the most heat; dramatic on trim, doors and modern siding
20 to 50Mid tones: most greens, blues and medium graysCan shift noticeably between sun and shade
50 to 75Light: soft grays, greiges, pale colorsVersatile body colors that still show detail
Above 75Very light and whitesReflects the most light and heat; shows dirt more readily

Can you paint vinyl siding a dark color?

Only with the right product. Darker paint absorbs more heat from the sun and passes it into the vinyl, which can expand past the point where it returns to shape, causing warping or buckling. Sherwin-Williams advises painting vinyl siding no darker than its original color unless you use its VinylSafe colors, a set that includes a limited selection of darker colors formulated to resist warping on sound, stable siding. It also notes that oil-based coatings are not recommended on vinyl because they are not flexible enough.

Which paint sheen should you use outside?

Use a lower sheen on siding and a higher sheen on trim and doors. Lower sheens hide surface flaws and uneven siding. Higher sheens are easier to clean and highlight architectural details.

Common exterior sheen choices by surface
SurfaceCommon sheenWhy
Siding (body)Flat, low lustre or satinHides imperfections; low lustre and satin clean more easily than flat
Trim, fascia, window casingsSatin or soft glossEasier to wipe clean; adds subtle contrast to the body
Front doors and shuttersSatin to glossMost durable and washable; makes the accent color stand out

How do you test exterior paint colors?

On the house, in daylight, at a large size. Screens and small chips are not accurate enough for a final decision. Jackie Jordan, director of color marketing at Sherwin-Williams, advises placing chips or painted testers against the other finishes on the house, and says the larger the sample, the better.

  1. Narrow it to two or three options for each color in the scheme.
  2. Paint large sample boards, or large sections of a spare siding panel, instead of small swatches.
  3. Place them on at least two sides of the house, including one that gets full sun and one that stays shaded.
  4. Look at them in the morning and again in the late afternoon. North and south exposures can make the same color look noticeably different.
  5. View them from the street, where most people will see the house.

Do you need HOA approval for exterior colors?

If your home is in a homeowners association, check your covenants before you buy paint. Many HOAs require approval for exterior color changes or keep an approved palette. Get approval in writing before the work is scheduled.

Get a professional color consultation

QC offers a complimentary color consultation. With our professional expertise, we help you navigate color combinations, undertones and finishes to find a palette that complements your home and brings your vision to life.

Frequently asked questions

Should exterior trim be lighter or darker than the siding?

Either works. Light trim on a darker body is the classic look and outlines the windows and roofline. Dark trim on a light body reads more modern. What matters is enough contrast that the trim is intentional, and colors that share an undertone.

What is a good LRV for exterior paint?

There is no single right number. Colors above about 50 read light and reflect more heat, which suits large body areas and vinyl siding. Colors below about 20 are very dark and absorb the most heat, so they are often used on trim, doors or materials rated for dark colors.

How big should exterior paint samples be?

As big as practical. Sherwin-Williams' director of color marketing says the larger the sample, the better. Large painted boards placed on more than one side of the house are far more reliable than small chips.

Why does my paint color look different on the house than on the chip?

Outdoor light is stronger and changes through the day, large areas intensify undertones, and the colors around it (roof, brick, landscaping) shift how it reads. Most colors look lighter and brighter outside than they do on a small chip indoors.

Can I paint vinyl siding a darker color?

Only with a product made for it. Sherwin-Williams recommends staying no darker than the siding's original color unless you use its VinylSafe colors, which include some darker shades formulated to resist warping.

Sources

  1. Pro Remodeler, How to Choose Exterior Colors (with Sherwin-Williams and LP SmartSide color experts)
  2. Sherwin-Williams, Vinyl Siding Warp (painting vinyl siding)
  3. Ring's End, Guide to Exterior Paint Sheens
  4. Benjamin Moore, Optimal Temperature to Paint Outside and Inside

More from the blog

All posts

Have a project in mind?

Send us the details and we will come take a look.

  • 5-Year Workmanship Warranty
  • Written estimate
  • Licensed, Bonded & Insured
Call NowGet a Free Estimate